The quiet village of Ohio City, nestled in Van Wert County, Ohio, was rocked by a harrowing tragedy on November 24, 2024. What began with a frantic phone call to authorities unfolded into a heartbreaking tale of violence, loss, and grief that has left the community reeling. The victims of this tragic event were identified as Shelby M. Coats, 29, of Ohio City, and Andrew C. Lause, 30, of Delphos, who were found dead in a home. The perpetrator, identified as Paul A. Boldman, 51, of Ohio City, was later discovered at another residence, where he succumbed to a self-inflicted gunshot wound.
At the heart of the tragedy lies the devastating impact on the victims’ families, particularly Shelby Coats’ two young daughters, Kimber, age 4, and Kora, just three months old. A GoFundMe campaign has been launched to support the family and help cover funeral expenses, with the community coming together to honor the lives of the deceased and provide for the young children left behind.
The Chain of Events
At approximately 8:09 a.m. on November 24, the Van Wert County Sheriff’s Office received a chilling call from an individual reporting that a friend had confessed to a double homicide and had indicated an intent to take his own life. The caller revealed that the friend had since left and was no longer with him. Deputies immediately responded, dividing their efforts between interviewing the caller for more information and acting on the initial details provided.
As investigators gathered leads, they were directed to a home in Ohio City, where the welfare of the residents was in question. Upon entering the residence, deputies were met with a grim scene. Both Shelby Coats and Andrew Lause were found inside, each having succumbed to gunshot wounds. The house was promptly secured, and the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation (BCI) was called in to assist with the processing of the crime scene.
Simultaneously, deputies tracked down a vehicle associated with the suspect, which led them to another residence. A perimeter was established, and law enforcement waited for a search warrant to enter the property. Upon gaining access, members of the Van Wert Police Department’s Special Response Team (SRT), along with deputies, found the suspect, Paul Boldman, still alive but critically injured from a self-inflicted gunshot wound. He was transported to Ohio Health Van Wert but was pronounced dead shortly after his arrival.
The Victims: Lives Cut Tragically Short
Shelby M. Coats, a 29-year-old nurse and mother of two, was described by friends and family as a loving, compassionate, and vibrant individual. Known for her dedication to her daughters, Kimber and Kora, Shelby balanced her professional responsibilities with her role as a devoted parent. Her best friend, Lexi, who initiated the GoFundMe campaign, described her as “the sweetest mother, nurse, daughter, friend, and overall person you could ever have the chance to know.”
Andrew C. Lause, a 30-year-old from Delphos, was equally cherished by those who knew him. Friends remember Andrew as a kind-hearted man who was always willing to lend a hand. His relationship with Shelby, though private, was said to be filled with mutual respect and affection. The circumstances that brought Andrew to the residence on the fateful morning remain under investigation.
The Perpetrator: A Troubled Path to Tragedy
Paul A. Boldman, 51, was identified as the individual responsible for the deaths of Shelby and Andrew. While the details of his relationship with the victims remain unclear, initial reports suggest a history of personal conflicts that may have escalated into violence. Boldman’s actions have left a community grappling with unanswered questions about what led to such a horrific outcome. Authorities continue to investigate the sequence of events and the possible motives behind the crime.
Community Response and Support
The tragedy has galvanized the small community of Ohio City, with residents coming together to support the grieving families. The GoFundMe campaign launched in Shelby’s memory aims to assist her mother, Sheryl, in covering funeral costs and providing for Kimber and Kora. The campaign has already garnered significant attention, with donors expressing their condolences and sharing heartfelt messages of support.
Lexi, the campaign organizer, emphasized the importance of community involvement during this difficult time. “Shelby was more than just a friend; she was family. We are determined to ensure her daughters are taken care of and that her legacy of kindness and love lives on.”
Investigation and Legal Proceedings
The Van Wert County Sheriff’s Office, in collaboration with the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation and other agencies, continues to probe the incident. Key aspects under review include the timeline of events, Boldman’s relationship with the victims, and any warning signs that may have been overlooked. The involvement of multiple law enforcement entities underscores the complexity of the case and the commitment to ensuring a thorough investigation.
The Van Wert County Coroner’s Office is working to finalize autopsy reports, which will provide further insight into the sequence of events. While the investigation remains ongoing, authorities have assured the community that every effort is being made to uncover the truth.
Remembering the Victims
As the community mourns the loss of Shelby and Andrew, plans are underway for memorial services to honor their lives. Friends, family, and colleagues have shared countless stories of the joy and positivity both individuals brought into the world. From Shelby’s dedication as a nurse to Andrew’s unwavering kindness, their legacies serve as a reminder of the fragility of life and the enduring impact of love and compassion.
A Call for Change
This tragedy has reignited conversations about mental health, domestic disputes, and the importance of community vigilance. Advocates are calling for increased resources and support systems to prevent similar incidents in the future. As Ohio City grapples with the aftermath of this devastating event, many are determined to channel their grief into action, fostering a safer and more supportive environment for all.
Conclusion
The deaths of Shelby Coats, Andrew Lause, and Paul Boldman have left an indelible mark on the Ohio City community. As the investigation unfolds, the focus remains on supporting the families affected by this senseless tragedy. Through collective grief and resilience, the community is working to honor the memories of those lost while seeking answers and healing.
